Hey Coach, I'm wondering whether you have the special edition versions of the Icons and Contours with the mice in them. Are you finding that the fridge gets rapidly depleted of cheese at night?
Seriously, are all these pairs of shoes squeaking, because I have never had that problem. FJ will look after you as your shoes will be under warranty and their customer care is top notch. I would follow Devin's advice and call customer care to enjoy the FJ back up experience. They are number 1 in golf shoes for a reason. Let us know how you get on.