Holy smokes Chuck! Both those ensembles are smashing. Even the watches and FJ bands match. Why are you asking me for advice?
But since you did.... If it were me.... The first outfit is probably the most logical, because if it were me, I would have a pair of Black/Lime Asyms to go with the lower outfit. You know, since I can never have enough black shoes, right Bobby! Perhaps you might also throw a black glove into the mix with the black shorts to keep that color theme going.
Really though, both of those are really top shelf. You keep this up and you're going to pass me by!