Player and comeback player: Tiger
I can't give it to Phil just because of one tournament. Tiger came back from reconstructive knee surgery, won 6 times and took home the FedEx. That's a resume for both honors as far as I am concerned.
I am very happy Phil won it and he had a very impressive 3 days of golf which is great for him and his confidence, but just by winning one tournament after not performing well in his last couple isn't grounds for comeback of the year for me.
Nonetheless, Congratulations to Phil and I look forward to his performance at the President's Cup.