It is hard to compare the PTL to any other glove out there. Not only is it the thinnest and softest glove you can get but the price point is not even close to that of the PermaSoft.
In trying to suggest alternative gloves, I had this in mind. It is difficult to suggest that someone try a $28 glove when they have been using a glove that costs $17.
I do agree that the PTL is the best glove out there, but if you are like me and use 3-4 dozen a year they get to be pretty expensive.